A paper towel holder may seem small, but it plays a big role in keeping your kitchen neat. Whether you’re cleaning spills or drying your hands, the right towel holder helps you tear off a piece of towel easily while keeping the paper towel roll steady.
Two of the top choices are the Simplehuman Quick-Load Paper Towel Holder and the OXO Good Grips SimplyTear Paper Towel Holder. Both have modern designs, durable materials, and one-handed tearing. But which one is best for your kitchen?
In this Simplehuman vs. OXO Paper Towel Holder comparison, we’ll look at their design, durability, performance, and value for money. By the end, you’ll know exactly which countertop paper towel holder is right for you.
Simplehuman vs OXO Quick Comparison Table
This table shows the key differences between the Simplehuman Quick-Load and the OXO Good Grips SimplyTear paper towel holders.
| Feature | Simplehuman Quick-Load | OXO Good Grips SimplyTear |
| Material | Brushed Stainless Steel | Alloy Steel & Stainless Steel |
| Design | Modern, sleek look | Classic design with a knob |
| Base | Heavy base for stability | Strong base with rubber grip |
| Tension Arm | Yes – Holds roll in place | Yes – Spring-loaded for control |
| One-Handed Tear | Yes – Easy to use | Yes – Smooth and effortless |
| Paper Towel Fit | Works with jumbo rolls | Fits all sizes |
| Setup | Freestanding – No installation needed | Freestanding – No installation needed |
| Extra Features | Finger loop for easy carrying | Spring arm for better grip |
| Check Price | Click here | Click here |
Design & Build Quality
A good towel holder should be strong and long-lasting. Both Simplehuman and OXO use high-quality stainless steel that looks great in any kitchen.
Simplehuman Quick-Load Paper Towel Holder
The Simplehuman paper towel holder has a sleek design with a stainless steel finish. It blends well with modern kitchen decor.
The weighted base keeps the paper towel roll steady, even when you tear off a piece of towel with one hand. It also has a finger loop, so you can move it easily.
OXO Good Grips SimplyTear Paper Towel Holder
The OXO Good Grips SimplyTear is made of alloy steel and brushed stainless steel. It has a modern yet classic look.
The sturdy base comes with a rubber grip, so it won’t slide. It also has a spring-activated arm that holds jumbo paper towel rolls in place.
Winner: Tie
Both holders are strong and stylish.
- Choose Simplehuman if you like a sleek, modern look.
- Pick OXO SimplyTear if you want a classic design with a tension arm for extra control.
Performance & Usability
Both paper towel holders are designed for easy, one-handed tearing. But which one works better in daily use?
Simplehuman Quick-Load
- The weighted base keeps it steady.
- The finger loop makes it easy to move.
- The tension arm holds the paper towel roll in place.
- Works well with jumbo rolls.
OXO SimplyTear
- The spring-activated arm adjusts to different paper towel roll sizes.
- The sturdy base prevents slipping.
- Works well with both cheaper paper towels and stronger paper towels.
Winner: OXO Good Grips SimplyTear
The spring-activated arm gives better control when tearing. This makes it slightly easier to use.
Pricing & Value for Money
These are not the cheapest paper towel holders, but they offer great quality and long-lasting durability.
- Simplehuman is best if you want a modern design, a stainless steel base, and easy portability.
- OXO SimplyTear is ideal if you need a spring-activated arm and a more stable base.
🔗 To check the latest price and any discounts, click below:
Who Should Buy Which One?
Buy Simplehuman If…
✅ You love a modern aesthetic that fits into contemporary kitchen settings.
✅ You need a lightweight towel holder with a finger loop for easy portability.
✅ You prefer a sleek, stainless steel design.
Buy OXO SimplyTear If…
✅ You want a spring-activated arm for better paper towel steady control.
✅ You need a strong contender that fits any type of paper towel.
✅ You want a countertop paper towel holder that works with jumbo paper towel rolls.
Final Winner – Which One is Best?
Both are great choices. But which one is best for you?
- Choose OXO Good Grips SimplyTear if you want a sturdy base and better control when tearing.
- Pick Simplehuman Quick-Load if you need a lightweight towel holder with a sleek design.
It all depends on what you value most in a paper towel holder!
FAQs About Simplehuman vs OXO Paper Towel Holder
1. Can I use a wall mount for these holders?
No, both are freestanding designs and are not meant to be wall-mounted paper towel holders.
2. Do these holders work with all size paper towel rolls?
Yes, both work with jumbo rolls, cheaper paper towels, and pieces of paper towel from different brands.
3. Are they easy to clean?
Yes! Both have a stainless steel finish, making them easy to wipe down.
4. Which one is better for counter space?
If you have limited counter space, the Simplehuman Quick-Load takes up less room.
5. Will the tension arm wear out over time?
Both holders are built with durable steel and should last for years with normal use.
Final Thoughts
Both the Simplehuman Quick-Load Paper Towel Holder and the OXO Good Grips SimplyTear are top-tier choices for anyone looking for a perfect paper towel holder.
- If you want a sleek, modern design, go with Simplehuman.
- If you prefer better control with a tension arm, choose OXO SimplyTear.
🔗 Ready to buy? Check the latest prices here:
No matter which one you choose, you’ll be investing in a high-quality, durable, and stylish paper towel holder for your kitchen. Happy shopping!
